Fashion - Written by admin on Sunday, November 23, 2008 2:15 - 0 Comments
SEARCH me: Null trial "morphed" into positive meta-analysis
|
HARLEY DAVIDSON FLH TEAL LOWER FAIRINGS WITH HARDWARE US $350.00 |
|
HARLEY DAVIDSON LOWER FAIRINGS W VENTS US $450.00 |
. Although the 80-mg dose failed to reduce vascular events significantly, there was a reduction in LDL with this higher dose, and the results are consistent with previous trials of more vs less statin, said the investigators.
(Clinical Trial Services Unit) discussed the results at a press conference. She said those who received the 80-mg dose of simvastatin had 0.35-mmol/L (14-mg/dL) lower LDL than those who got the 20-mg dose, which translated into a 6% further reduction in vascular events, “which on its own was not significant but is in line with all the other combined more-vs-less data. When we look at the combined data, we see a very clear picture emerging.”
(Emory University, Atlanta, GA), said: “This was a null trial that was morphed into a positive meta-analysis. I don’t want to be unfair, but I think that’s what we just saw.”
said they would likely chose a more potent statin than simvastatin if they needed to intensively lower LDL.
1 mg daily or placebo for the homocysteine-lowering comparison for a total of seven years.
The primary end point was major vascular events, consisting of major coronary events, stroke, and revascularization. For the more-vs-less-statin comparison, there was a further reduction of 0.35 mmol/L (14mg/dL) in LDL in the intensive arm compared with the 20-mg arm, equating to around a 14% further reduction in LDL, Collins noted.
But there was no difference in the primary end point between the groups: 1477 events (24.5%) in the 80-mg simvastatin group vs 1553 events (25.7%) in the lower-dose group (p=0.10).
Reassuringly, however, there was no evidence that further reducing LDL increased the risk of cancer, which has previously been a concern, Collins noted.
, said Armitage, and show that larger reductions in LDL with intensive statin therapy produce further reductions in each of the components of major vascular events, including revascularization and nonfatal MI/coronary death.
The combined evidence illustrates that further reducing LDL by 0.5 mmol/L provides an additional 16% relative reduction in vascular events, a 1.5-mmol/L decline provides a 33% relative risk reduction, and a 2-mmol/L drop gives a further 40% relative reduction in events, she concluded.
Discussant Wilson said the difference seen between the two statin groups in the SEARCH trial “was not enough to show that lower is better, and the LDL was only modestly lower in the 80-mg simvastatin group,” although he commented that a difference may have emerged had the trial lasted longer. “Does lower LDL lead to lower cardiovascular risk post-MI? The SEARCH trial didn’t answer that question,” he said.
“The LDL story from 80 to 100 is getting very solid,” he added, “but the challenge is what happens below 80. We don’t have the answer that many of us would like to know for the next round, below 70mg/dL.”
results, also reported today, give a hint of what to expect in this regard.
Also, more attention must be paid to absolute rather than relative risk reduction, Wilson stressed. “We’re growing more and more interested in absolute risk, which is 1% per year after a MI with a low-dose statin, and it’s not that much different with a high-dose statin. We now need to consider absolute risk and residual risk, which is a newer term referring to absolute risk for those getting the most benefit.”
Both Collins and Armitage flagged the fact that, in SEARCH, there was more myopathy in the 80-mg group, which Collins noted “was reported to regulators a few years ago and added to the data sheet.”
Armitage noted that the “vast majority of the patients taking 80 mg of simvastatin tolerated it well,” but for those who do develop myopathy there are a couple of options, she noted: the dose of statin can be reduced—”40 mg [of simvastatin] rarely causes myopathy”—or there is the option of trying to identify, via genetic means, those who are at increased risk of myopathy. (The Oxford team has identified a genetic marker for myopathy that accounts for 60% of myopathies, Collins said.)
Tomaselli said that faced with a patient who required intensive lipid lowering, he would opt for one of the more potent statins over 80 mg of simvastatin.
(Monash University, Melbourne, Australia) agreed. “SEARCH is really consistent with other trials that lower is better, and it extends the evidence base.” He, too, said he would opt for a more potent statin: “It’s always good to start a statin at a dose that is well tolerated and gets people to target quickly,” he said. “For me, that would be rosuvastatin or atorvastatin.”
arm vs 1493 in the placebo arm, to give a risk ratio of 1.04.
Armitage said there is “clear evidence from SEARCH that homocysteine lowering does not affect the risk of vascular events—it’s really a very robustly negative result, and there were no subgroups in whom there was any benefit.” Collins concurred: “We can now rule out unequivocally any effects of homocysteine lowering on vascular events,” he noted.
—specifically, no increase in the risk of cancer—something that is of “particular importance” because of the fortification of food with folic acid in many countries.
, and she reported on a meta-analysis of all these trials, including SEARCH.
Discussant Wilson said: “We just saw four different presentations: one on statins in SEARCH, one on homocysteine in SEARCH, and two meta-analyses.”
Wilson said the homocysteine side of the trial “is discouraging. The numbers from SEARCH fit right into the portfolio. We would like to think that taking B vitamins would improve things, but these vitamins are not preventing recurrent events in this trial.” However, “B vitamins are safe; we’ve known that for a while,” he added.
“The door is slowly closing on the homocysteine-lowering hypothesis for cardiovascular disease prevention,” he concluded.
But Tomaselli said he does not believe that SEARCH sounds a death note for the homocysteine hypothesis; however, it does “strike a note of caution. There are plenty of biological plausibility studies and reasons to believe that lowering homocysteine will lower risk, but the methods currently used to lower it are not effective. “We need to better understand how to lower homocysteine to lower risk,” he commented.
Related Story
Most Popular Content
- No parole for DownsConvicted killer remains a remorseless liar
- Alaska’s wilderness confounds self-importance
- Saatzer bowling column: ATS edges Granite Bowl for USBC title
- Public records for Dec. 9, 2008
- BIRTH ANNOUNCEMENTS 12/07
- PREP BASKETBALL: Non-Conference
- Sorel Sponsors US Snowboarding National Team
- Morning News Digest: Friday, December 12, 2008
- Backups Forecast for Highway 16 This Weekend
- Restaurants, institutions work to cut expenses from leftovers
- Cosmic Corey Blog: December 2008
- It was really hard for me to think back and remember my first theater experience...
- Most people feel that it is more profitable to play heads up , since it can be v...
- No comment as yet, but would like to know if there will be a website for Westfie...
- Thank you to HSUS, Farm Sanctuary, the Animal Protection and Rescue League, Anim...
- Hello. I was reading someone elses blog and saw you on their blogroll. Would y...
- Agree with most of what you say except she is not the innocent you suggest. A lo...
- Very detailed, in depth, informative reporting - as usual....
Sports - Dec 21, 2008 10:52 - 0 Comments
Week 12 Review: Florida rolls over South Carolina
More In Sports
- Heavy lake-effect snow hits Great Lakes states, closing some schools
- WV forum ponders closed high school campus
- Fatality? Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe Now in Stores
- David Wright fine with Francisco Rodriguez or Brian Fuentes
- City officials rehash green ideas
Entertainment - Dec 25, 2008 16:43 - 0 Comments
Twilight premiere
More In Entertainment
- Fan throws party for "Twilight" premiere
- Robert Pattison and Kristen Stewart Premiere “Twilight”
- Comic Book Artist Jock Shows Off His Christina Aguilera ‘Catwoman …
- WIN: Hancock DVD
- ‘I want some answers’
Polity - Dec 15, 2008 13:36 - 0 Comments
First Look At Robot Chicken’s Star Wars Extravaganza
More In Polity
- Ever lied to a friend about something being good just so you …
- Palin often criticized by Alaska Natives as unresponsive
- Lobbyist in Push to Curb Online Gambling Faulted
- NORTH LAS VEGAS GAMING: Aliante fires up
- Cadillac Obama








Leave a Reply